Belajar melalui Praktik Global: Pengaturan Densitas Daerah dan Batas Maksimum Ketinggian Bangunan
Keywords:
spatial planning, building height, sociospatial issuesAbstract
This article focusses on the significance of non-physical aspects in regulating the maximum height of buildings, a determining element of urban density. Here, it addresses global practices that underline this dimension of the issue. The paper uses four significant classifications, namely: (i) safeguarding historical legacies; (ii) implementation of values and practices pertaining to systems of belief; (iii) political objectives; and (iv) the creation and the strengthening of an urban image. Each category impacts on development in regard to space. Overall, they have become determinants in limiting height, they have laid a foundation for the instigation of relevant development control policies, and have even been considered as red lights to the relaxation of a current building height restriction. Similarly, the paper has four sections. The first examines the importance of building height regulation within the context of spatial planning. The second discusses the position of sociospatial issues within the planning process. The third explores the role and position of the four non-physical aspects defined above, in policing building height. The fourth section synthesises effects and conclusion.
Downloads
References
(China Daily, dalam http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/english/doc/2005-
03/03/content_421298.htm, diakses 10/08/08).
Attoe, W. (1981) Skylines: Understanding and Molding Urban Silhouettes
Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
Chapin Jr, F S. (1957) Urban land Use United Governments of America
(New York): Harper & Brothers Publisher.
Cuthbert, A R (1985) Architecture, Society and Space. The High Density
Question Revisited. Progress in Planning 24, Oxford (UK):
Pergamon Press, p: 71-160.
Cuthbert, A R (2006) The Form of Cities: Political economy and Urban
Design United Kingdon: Blackwell Publishing.
Ellis, C (2002) The new urbanism: critiques and rebuttals The Journal of
Urban Design 7 (3), p: 261- 292.
Evans, G (2001) Cultural Planning: An Urban Renaissance? New York:
Routledge.
Hague, C (2000) ‘What is Planning and What do Planners do?’ in
Allmendinger, P, Prior, A, and Raemaekers, J (Eds.) Introduction
to Planning Practice Chichester (England): John Willey & Sons,
Ltd.
Holmes, S. (2004) ‘The History and Effects of Changes, Past and Present,
to London’s Skyline,’ http://www.users.brookes.ac.uk/01231893/,
Diakses 08/09/2008.
Hong Kong SAR Government (1999) Sustainable Development in Hong
Kong for the 21st Century: Second Statge Consultation Document
Hong Kong SAR: Hong Kong SAR Government.
Japan Times (02 Sept.2007) ‘Kyoto Enforces Ad Ban, Building Height
Changes’ in Japan Times Japan.
Jenks, M and Burgess, R (2000) Compact Cities: Sustainable Urban Forms
for Developing Countries London: Spon
Kaiser, E J, D R Godschalk, F S Chapin Jr (1995) Urban land Use Planning
United Governments of America: University of Illinois Press.
Kerr, Alex (1996) Lost Japan (4th ed.) Vic., Australia: Hawthorn.
Layman, R. Rents and Height Limits in http://urbanplacesandspaces.
blogspot.com/2008/05/rents-and-height-limits.html accessed
06/06/08).
Lewis, R.K. (26 May 2007) ‘There is Nothing Sacred about the Building
Height Limit’ dalam Washington Post The United States of
America.
Mayor of London (2002) The Draft London Plan: Draft Spatial Development
Strategy for Greater London London: Greater London Authority.
Miao, P (2001) Public Places in Asian Pacific Cities Amsterdam: Kluwer.
Ng, E. (2005) ‘Towards a Better Building and Urban Design in Hong
Kong’ Proceedings for International Conference “Passive and Low
Energy Cooling for the Built Environment” May 2005, Santorini,
Greece.
Orbash, A (2000) Tourists in Historic Towns London: Spon.
Ouf, A M S (2001) Authenticity and the sense of place in urban design
The Journal of Urban design 6 (1).
Punter, J. (1999) Design Guidelines in American Cities: A Review od Design
Policies and Guidance in Five West Coast Cities Liverpool (USA):
Liverpool University Press.
Raemaekers, J (2000) ‘Planning for Sustainable Development’ in
Allmendinger, P, Prior, A, and Raemaekers, J (Eds.) Introduction
to Planning Practice Chichester (England): John Willey & Sons,
Ltd.
Rybczynski, W in http://urbanplacesandspaces.blogspot.com/ 2008/04/
cairo-hotel-washington-dc.html, diakses 10/07/08.
Samuel, H (8 Juli 2008) ‘Paris Mayor Proposes High-Rise Changes to
City Skyline’ in Telegraph. United Kingdom.
Schiller, S., Evans, J.H. (2000) ‘ Urban Climate and Compact Cities in
Developing Countries’ in Jenks, M, Burgess, R (Eds.) Compact
Cities Sustainable Urban Forms for Developing Countries London:
Spon Press, Taylor & Francis Group
Simon, R.D. (1996) Skyscrapers and the New London Skyline: 1945-
1991, The Electronic Journal of Architecture, http://architronic.
saed.kent.edu/v5n2/v5n2.06a.html, Diakses 08/09/2008.
Smith, C.H. (07/11/2005) ‘The Downside of Density’ http://www.
oftwominds.com/blogjan06/bldg-heights2.html,diakses
08/07/2008.
Smith, C.H. (21/06/2006) ‘Building Height, Density and Liveability’
http://www.oftwominds.com/blogjan06/bldg-heights2.html,
accessed 8/07/2008.
Suartika, G.A.M. (2008a) ’Kajian Produk Regulasi Keruangan:
Mempertanyakan Batas Ketinggian Bangunan Di Bali’ Proceedings
Seminar Jelajah Negeri Seri ke-3: Ajeg Bali: Tradisionalitas dalam
Modernitas, Werdhapura (Sanur), Bali, 1-3 Juli.
Suartika, G.A.M. (2008b) ’Arsitektur Organik Dan Tradisi Keruangan:
Setinggi Pohon Nyiur Di Bali’ Proceedings Seminar Arsitektur
Nusantara, Surabaya 12 September.
Suartika,G A M (2007) ‘Territoriality and the market system – Adat land
vs. state regulations on land matters in Bali’ Habitat International
Journal, 31 (2007): 167-176.
Wansborough, M and Mageean, A (2000) The role of urban design in
cultural regeneration The Journal of Urban Design 5 (2), p: 181-
198.
Waters, M (2000) Globalisation 2nd ed. London: Routledge.
Williams, K., Burton, E., and Jenks, M.(Eds.) (2000) Achieving Sustainable
Urban Form London: E & FN Spon.
Zhang, X Q (2000) High rise and high density compact urban form.
The development of Hong Kong, in Jenks, M and Burgess, R
Compact Cities: Sustainable Urban Forms for Developing Countries
London: Spon.













